Crime in China And Your Safety
February 18th, 2007
Whether you are one of our older or younger MBA students, I suspect that when your parents found out we/you were going to China, they may have said the same thing my own mother asked me when I started pulling this trip together several years ago and that she still asks me each year because she loves her youngest boy and wants him to stay safe: “Oh my goodness. I hear it’s not very safe there. Why don’t you go to England or Italy?”
Five thoughts:
1. Yeah, right, Mom. Like lilly white Europe is any safer! I was once mugged in a train station in Milan. I was once peed on by a drugged out Frenchman in a park in Paris because he felt, in his apparent state of hallucenating, that my 25 feet away from him while walking along a flower path in the garden was not far enough from him (in the US we call that an assault and battery). I was once caught in the middle of an ugly soccer hooligan brawl (more like a riot) in a pub in London, where I was really, really scared and just wanted to crawl under a table to make sure I survived.
2. China is where business is happening right now. In my own bullish (and admittedly biased) view on China, it is the future of business for at least the next several decades. Let’s go see and experience it while we can. Crime occurs everywhere, including in California.
3. I have never felt unsafe in China. But, I am a pretty big guy and I ALWAYS try to be aware of my surroundings and try not to make stupid decisions that put me in danger. I agree with Dan Harris’ recent CLB post, “Mapping Crime in China and Democracy in Action” (a must read; check it out) where he writes:
“When clients ask me whether they need to worry about crime in China, I typically say it is hard to know because the statistics are so unreliable…. I then talk about ‘my sense’ of things, based on my own experiences (so far, so good) and that of the people I know (both Chinese and foreign) in China (mostly petty crimes like pickpocketing).”
That has been my experience as well. Dan goes on to note:
“[T]he Danwei blog just did a great post, entitled, ‘Thief Maps Let Netizens Fight Crime,’ on the growing phenomenon in China of citizens mapping out crime locations on the Internet using “thief maps.” These maps are set up so users can contribute their individual run-ins with thieves and those incidents get mapped.”
Be sure to check out this Danwei post. This is an absolutely fascinating development. Is this, as Dan writes, democracy in action in China because by letting this occur on the Internet the government is in effect admitting they can’t handle this facet of crime effectively and by letting citizens take this into their own hands they are allowing some meaningful freedom of association and assembly to occur? I think so, and agree with Dan on this point. If so, this is pretty powerful stuff and China may, indeed, be changing for the better, albeit slowly.
4. I also sense and smell a business opportunity or two in this “Netizens Fight Crime” development in China. Do you, and if so, what do you see and smell?
As an MBA student, I want you to come out of our program always looking for and being able to quickly recognize business opportunities, because you will find you will have to reinvent yourselves professionally every so many years as you change, as the economy changes, your firm changes and/or your industry changes.
5. While we are in China, here I again repeat what I have advised you before on several occasions – always be aware of your surroundings, keep your bags/luggage close to you and your eye on them, look out for each other, and NEVER get drunk during your off time and thereby make yourself a prime target for crime and thieves, etc. (see, e.g., my earlier related post, Burning A Hole In Your Stomach, Chinese Style). (Several of the questions in your Frequently Asked Questions document also address these and other points.) I.e., be and remain the smart Cal Poly MBA students with good judgment that you are.
Entry Filed under: Pre-Departure, China, Misc.
2 Comments Add your own
1. Patrick McGuire | March 5th, 2007 at 11:24 pm
I’ve heard the very same questions myself. I mentioned the China tour to some family friends and was asked why we were going to such a “risky” place. But really, I can think of so many “safe,” Western places I have visited and been asked the very same thing! The most notalble was Northern Ireland. I heard many people asking me why I was going to such a “dangerous” place, if I was afraid of bombings, etc. The truth is that Northern Ireland was a beautiful place and I never once felt I was at any greater safety risk that every day I’ve lived in California. In fact, if you look at the statistics, it’s an extremely exaggerted risk. In the past 40 years, fewer than 2,000 civilians have been killed in “The Troubles” in Northern Ireland. That’s about 50 per year, or 1 in 74,000 (when you factor in the population of the area plus the number of visits in 2006. You’re more than 12 times more likely to be killed in a car accident, but I haven’t heard many people asking why I was doing something so dangerous as riding in a car! Not to mention that so much of that was concentrated in a certain part of town that I would not be visiting and that peace agreements have dropped the risk to virtually zero in the last few years. I suspect that the safety “threats” of China are also grossly exaggerated.
So much of our idea of which places are safe is so skewed by anecdotal news reports. Most places in the world are safe if you practice due diligence.
What it really comes down to is not being stupid. There are the right places to go and the wrong places to go. If we’re responsible about where we take ourselves, we’ll stay away from the risky places. You wouldn’t walk down the street in most American cities all alone at night wearing a really nice watch and you shouldn’t do that in China either. Just like in general business, due diligence is key.
Now, on the topic of not being stupid, we of course have heard reports that skew on the other side of the Crime and Punishment scale–going up against law enforcement. China is protective of its culture and sense of decency. I have heard stories of tourists being given a thorough questioning for bringing in more than a “personal” amount of religious material, music with “indecent” overtones, or anything that they feel might threaten the Chinese way of life. Now, I doubt they open up every suitcase and pull each and every item out at the International arrivals gate, but again, the key is just not to be stupid and try to test it or assume that your suitcase is your business. They can keep you from coming in if they want to.
2. Chris Carr | March 6th, 2007 at 9:01 am
Good comment.
Leave a Comment
Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed