In Rubble, Couple Clung To Each Other, And To Life

This NY Times article will blow you away.

14 comments May 18th, 2008

Chinese Ethnocentrism. Just As Hard To Accept As Western Ethnocentrism.

Westerners can be ethnocentric (see, e.g., my previous post and our comment discussion, Cultural Knuckleheads in the Global World); but let’s be fair — so can others, including the Chinese. And per Dr. Morris’ lecture with us we learned that a fair bit of this stems from China’s historical “we are the Middle Kingdom” and our emperor has a “mandate from Heaven” cultural superiority/bias/thing and that house of cards. On either side of the Pacific, ethnocentrism is not terribly attractive, in my view.

I also see over-the-top nationalism to be a subset of ethnocentrism. Example: “I love my country” = okay and it seems to me is not ethnocentric and is legitimate patriotism. But “I love my country because we are the best at or we have the best ____” or “We’re Number One!” many times = obnoxious nationalism and hence ethnocentrism (particularly when said by one who has not traveled much to be able to have a decent sample size to gauge what the “best” or “No. 1″ is or by someone who is afraid to try new things and/or is not terribly adventurous).

Yes, the line between legitimate patriotism and obnoxious nationalism is fine, but it’s important. It’s easy to tip from one into the other.

See Dan Harris’ recent China Law Blog post on this very subject (Chinese nationalism) and how it relates to business. It’s worth the read.

Some will argue one side caused or led to the other’s grief. I have no idea how to sort out the casual chain. Others will offer excuses for their ethnocentrism (whether it’s western, eastern, northern hemisphere, southern hemisphere, or other) (e.g., “But you misunderstand me. I am not really that way as a person; and how can I be classified as ethnocentric for believing what I believe. That’s not fair. And in any event, I am right, you know.”). That stuff does not much matter to me. At some point, we all just need to get over the reasons and excuses, cut out the feeling of being right and/or superior to the other, and move forward.

Your thoughts?

Prof. Carr June 10, 2008 addendum: See the WSJ article that just came out relating to this very post, Victim or Victor? China’s Olympic Odyssey

5 comments May 18th, 2008

National Geographic Specials on China

A hat tip to Gary Chou for sending me the below link. I am a National Geographic subscriber, remember the below issue coming out and reading it, but I forgot to put up a post and the issue had since disappeared into the mess on my office desk at home.

Click HERE to check out these great pics on China’s Instant Cities (the photo gallery link is on the right side of the page; the commentary by Peter Hessler is top notch, as is all of his work - e.g., Two Years on the Yangtze). And reading this very good Wall Street Journal article, On the Move: Chinese Officials Want More Farmers to Migrate to the City; But They Are Also Aware That Migration Brings Problems, will put these photos into a good big picture context for you.

Finally, last month, April 2008, National Geographic published a special issue only on China called, China: Inside the Dragon. Check it out. Again, some great short pieces by Peter Hessler and the usual amazing pictures. You can also click HERE to listen to the China Business Network’s recent podcast interview of the Editor-in-Chief of National Geographic Magazine, Chris Johns, about this issue on China. I also had no idea National Geographic is read by 40 to 45 million people each month. Cha-ching. And talk about a company that has put on a clinic for others re: how to manage and build its brand ….

Enjoy.

Prof. Carr June 13, 2008 addendum: see also this related post on instant city Shenzhen I just made (Shenzhen is located in southern China).

1 comment May 18th, 2008