Traditional India vs. New Age India
Submitted by: Ashley Breneman
On January 24th, women drinking at a bar in Mangalore, India were attacked by a group of approximately 40 men representing Sri Ram Sena, “the Army of Ram.” The women were attacked for being “un-Indian” by being out drinking and dancing with men. The new pub culture in India has been strongly debated across the country on various talk shows. The conservative group known as The Sena appeared on television saying that his group had “stepped in to enforce morality since the government had failed.” The following video describes the attack:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJpSfV-UmIY&NR=1
Many have shown opposition for this group, but politicians have made few announcements on the topic. Women and child development minister, Renuka Chowdhury, has criticized the Sena, calling its methods “Talibanization.” Many women across India have protested that they have a right to go to the pubs. Although a lot of the Indian culture is still very conservative, this proves that many women in the Indian society are striving towards a more Western view on women’s rights.
The struggle for equality is more of a battle of culture. From what we have learned up until now, the women in India are treated very respectfully. The issues being brought up by the Sena are resulting from a deviation from the traditional Indian ideals of how a woman should act. These new-age women feel they have a right to go out and drink at the pubs, just as men do. The following debate on CNN-IBN about Mangalore morality and culture shows just how heated these debates have been.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQrYgkBBryw
After learning about these attacks on women, I understand why it is so important that we go out in groups and more importantly, always have a guy with us. It also demonstrates why it is crucial that we understand the cultural differences in both China and India. A bar in India is not the same as a bar in San Luis Obispo, and treating it as so can get any one of us into a great deal of trouble. Hopefully with this knowledge and a little common sense, none of us will encounter any problems. The videos shown reinforce why we should never drink on the streets, and why we should always exhibit caution and respect if we do decide to consume an alcoholic beverage.
The article describing the incident can be read on The New York Times website:
10 comments May 26th, 2009